Rear Window Reflections: A Knee Surgery Journey

Uday Dandavate
5 min readJul 30, 2024

--

As I lay here, confined to my bed after knee surgery, I can’t help but feel like a modern-day Jeffries from Alfred Hitchcock’s “Rear Window.” My days are spent observing my surroundings, pondering the intricacies of my recent surgery, and weaving together stories from the fragments of information I’ve collected.

This poem is an exploration of my personal journey, beginning with the anesthetic-induced fog of the surgery room and continuing through the recovery process. As I recount my experiences and reflections, I invite you to join me in questioning the nature of knowledge and the limits of our understanding.

Through this introspective journey, I delve into the human tendency to construct narratives from incomplete information, using my own healing process as a backdrop. Ultimately, I hope to shed light on the interconnectedness of personal experience and the universal struggle to make sense of the world around us.

As I was rolled into

the operating theater,

I glanced around the room.

I counted ten or twelve of them,

wearing face masks,

green robes,

and white headgear.

Each one was busy

preparing their tools;

the only person

who stood out to me

was the surgeon,

sitting on a chair,

awaiting my arrival.

As soon as I was in position,

the surgeon said

to his team,

“Are we all ready to start?”

And everyone responded

in a melodious chorus,

“Oh, yeah!”

The anesthetist

turned to me,

ready to give an injection

in my spine.

As I started anticipating

a prick in my spine,

I heard his soft voice asking me,

“Uday, what’s your

favorite alcohol?”

As I answered his question,

in a voice loud and clear,

everyone in the room

seemed particularly interested

in knowing more about

The Monkey Shoulder,

a German gin.

As I tried to respond

to the questions

from one corner of the room

to the other,

the room went silent.

And in a blink,

I heard the soft whisper of

the anesthetist,

“We are done.”

I said to him,

“What? No way!

I just heard you all

ask me questions

about Monkey Shoulder!”

The anesthetist smiled

and said, “You did well.”

There was no way for me to know

that the surgery was done.

I was sedated;

there was no pain.

The only way for me to know

that the surgery was done

was when nurses and doctors

visited me,

one after the other,

to make sure I was okay.

The surgeon stopped by.

When I asked him

what was involved

in replacing a knee,

he said, amidst many other things,

sawing, hammering, and drilling.

I was intrigued;

I found a YouTube video

to revisit

what my surgery

may have been like.

Now I know

what happened

between the conversation

about Monkey Shoulder

and the anesthetist’s visit

to my bedside:

The surgeon

first made a mark on my knee

with a Sharpie.

He made a superficial cut

into my knee

and opened the wound wide.

He put the kneecap aside,

took a scalpel in hand,

and started removing

the debris of the meniscus.

He used the tibial cutting jig

to make a flat cut

on the shin bone,

perpendicular to

the long axis of

the shin bone.

Then, he put a rod

down the center of

the side bone,

and removed

some of the bone spur

and torn cartilage

with a chisel and a hammer.

The next thing was to

remove the end

of the side bone

at a perfect angle.

They prepared the kneecap

by removing

some of the inside tissue.

Next, they placed

trial components

for patella and tibia

to ensure

the movement of the leg

was perfect.

They adjusted

the ligaments

to ensure that

they were

balanced appropriately.

Once satisfied,

they removed

the trial components

and prepared to place

the real ones.

First, they applied

blue cement

that looked like putty

with a glue gun.

They started with

the shin bone,

placed the prosthesis,

and hammered it in place.

Once in place,

they cleaned out the

excess cement

and allowed it to harden

through an exothermic reaction.

They checked the leg movement

to make sure everything

was working fine.

Finally, they stitched me up.

As I finished watching

the YouTube video,

I remembered

asking the anesthetist

if there was a possibility

for me to watch

the surgery in real time.

Could he give me

such an anesthetic?

I’m glad there wasn’t

such an option.

I would have been

a disruption,

asking too many questions.

On YouTube, I could

pause and rewind.

While watching the surgery,

I could neither pause

nor rewind,

but on YouTube,

I could simulate a mental image

of my own surgery

in progress.

I moved to

my daughter’s and

son-in-law’s house

for recuperation.

“Baba got a new knee,”

we told our granddaughter,

who was wondering

why I was in bed

with a bandage on my knee.

Auggie, the Labradoodle,

was concerned and amused.

He tried to sniff my bandage

but was quickly turned away.

Lying in bed

with my feet raised

above heart level,

and the knee wrapped

in the ice machine pad,

all the voices of hope

came back to me.

“Your life will change

once you’re back

on your feet,”

said all my friends.

While we were still

in the hospital,

we received the news

that my wife’s mother

was in the ICU in Mumbai.

It was a catch-22 situation:

decide

if my wife should leave

for India

or attend to me.

We booked a flight for her

a week after my return

from the hospital.

Alas,

two days after my return,

we heard the news

of her passing away.

The pain of losing her

could not be suppressed

by the painkillers

I was taking

for post-surgery healing.

As I lay in bed

with my leg raised,

I remembered the movie

“Rear Window” by Alfred Hitchcock.

In this movie,

Jeffries, a photographer

with a broken leg,

obsesses over observing

his neighbors,

keeps building scenarios,

and makes assumptions

about a murder he witnesses

in the neighbor’s house.

The film demonstrates

how the human mind creates

imaginary stories

based on limited information.

As I thought about Jeffries,

I realized that

in my state of confinement,

I, too, am making stories

in my head

with limited information

I am receiving.

I wondered,

aren’t we all

often making stories

with limited information?

The point made

in “Rear Window” is

that it’s important

to question the veracity

or completeness

of available information

while making stories

and to keep revising

the stories we make

as we collect

more information.

I wondered,

how did surgery begin?

Was it with complete knowledge

of human anatomy?

Did the first person

who used the scalpel

to cut open a human body

have all the knowledge

of the procedure?

or did they work with

incomplete stories?

The surgeon

who worked on my knee,

knowing everything

there is to know

in medical science

about knee surgery,

may not know

what he will know

in the future about

human anatomy and surgery.

As I heal,

I’ve come to see

That recovery’s not just physical,

But of mind and soul, too,

As knowledge’s limits expand.

--

--

Uday Dandavate
Uday Dandavate

Written by Uday Dandavate

A design activist and ethnographer of social imagination.

No responses yet